Online Ordering
You can order online! Browse our menu items and choose what you’d like to order from us.
Online Ordering Menu
All of our treats are baked fresh to order, made with love, and prepared just for you. Choose your favorites, build your flavor, and we’ll handle the rest. 🗓 Delivery Days: Online orders are delivered on Wednesdays and Fridays. ✨ Need your order for a specific date? If you need an order for a specific date/event outside of our regular delivery days, please submit a Catering Request so we can make it happen. 🎂 Looking for a cake? Cakes aren’t available through online ordering. For custom cakes, please use our Cake Order Request Form. Thanks for choosing Milk Me Treats — we can’t wait to bake something sweet for you!
Seasonal & Limited Edition Treats
A rotating selection of seasonal desserts, specialty flavors, and limited-time creations. These treats are only available for a short time while supplies last.
Easter Treat Bundle - Mix & Match
Mix and match your own Easter treats bundles! Choose from either one 4in round cake w/ 6 treats or a dozen Easter treats. Please read through the options carefully and select your flavors under the correct treat types. Order Deadline: 4/2/2026 Pickup/Delivery Dates: 4/3/2026 & 4/4/2026
$35.00 - Unavailable
BYOF - Build Your Own Flavor
This is where creativity meets dessert. 🍪🧁Choose your base, pick your mix-ins, and make it your own. Our BYOF options include cookies, vegan/gluten-free cookies, and brownies — build a flavor that’s uniquely yours.
BYOF Cookies
Pick your base, mix-ins, toppings and make it your own. 🍪
$15.00
BYOF V/GF Cookies
Pick your base, mix-ins, toppings and make it your own. 🍪
$17.00
BYOF Brownies & Blondies
Pick your base, mix-ins, toppings and make it your own. 🍫
$15.00
MMT Signature Treats
Can’t decide? Start here. These Milk Me Treats favorites are pre-curated and guaranteed to hit the sweet spot. Thoughtfully crafted, baked fresh, and ready to enjoy.
Cookies
These are our tried-and-true favorites — Milk Me Treats classics crafted with care and baked fresh to order.
$15.00
Brownies & Blondies
Rich, fudgy brownies and golden blondies made to satisfy every sweet craving.
$15.00
Jumbo Cupcakes
Oversized, bakery-style cupcakes with bold flavors and generous frosting, for maximum indulgence.
$25.00
Jumbo Muffins
Large, flavorful muffins baked fresh and perfect for breakfast, brunch, or a sweet pick-me-up.
$24.00
Regular Cupcakes
Classic cupcakes with balanced flavors and smooth frosting — simple, sweet, and satisfying.
$16.00
Regular Muffins
Freshly baked muffins with comforting flavors, perfect for everyday treats or sharing.
$15.00
Mini Bundt Cakes
Perfectly portioned mini bundt cakes with rich flavors and beautiful finishes.
$18.00
Danishes
Buttery, flaky danishes filled with sweet flavors for a light yet indulgent treat.
$18.00
Sammy's (Sandwich Cookies)
Soft, chewy cookies sandwiched with creamy fillings.
$20.00
Lactation Treats
Thoughtfully baked treats made with lactation-friendly ingredients and customizable flavors, created to support mothers on their breastfeeding journey.
Lactation Cookies
Soft, comforting cookies made with lactation-friendly ingredients, made to support you during this season.
$24.00
Lactation Bites
Perfectly portioned, grab-and-go bites made with lactation-friendly ingredients - perfect for easy snacking.
$16.00
Lactation Bars
Hearty, satisfying bars crafted with lactation-friendly ingredients.
$24.00
Lactation Brownies & Blondies
Rich brownies and blondies made with lactation-friendly ingredients, baked fresh for a comforting sweet treat.
$15.00
Vegan/GF Lactation Cookies
Plant-based, gluten-free cookies made with lactation-friendly ingredients and baked fresh without sacrificing flavor.
$26.00
Vegan/GF Lactation Bites
Vegan and gluten-free snackable bites made with lactation-friendly ingredients.
$18.00
Vegan/GF Lactation Bars
Vegan and gluten-free bars made with lactation-friendly ingredients.
$26.00
